Export settings not working

My game is working fine in editor but when I go to export/package the project into an exe, its very very laggy. It sounds like the export settings are to blame.

So I modified the export settings to low, rebuilt everything, and exported/packaged the project again but I still have the same issue. Am I missing something? Is there a different location for export settings?

I believe the culprit was this needing to be set to “Always”: